Research Article: 2024 Vol: 27 Issue: 3
Zhang Jing, Universitas Medan Area
Dr. Rizkan Zulyadi, Universitas Medan Area
Dr. M. Citra Ramadhan, Universitas Medan Area
Citation Information: Jhing Z., Zulyadi R., Ramadhan M.C , (2024). Exploring international commercial law in china: A comprehensive analysis for students. Journal of Legal, Ethical and Regulatory Issues, 27(3), 1-11.
This research paper embarks on a comprehensive exploration of the multifaceted domain of International Commercial Law, specifically within the unique landscape of China. It endeavors to equip students with a robust comprehension of the foundational principles, intricate applications, and profound significance underlying this pivotal area of legal study. Employing a simplified approach, the paper endeavors to demystify the complexities surrounding International Commercial Law, unraveling its core tenets, legal frameworks, and real-world implications. By elucidating key concepts and principles, the paper empowers students with the requisite knowledge and insight to effectively navigate the intricate terrain of international business transactions within the Chinese context. With a focus on accessibility and clarity, the research paper endeavors to elucidate the practical implications of International Commercial Law for students aspiring to engage in cross-border commerce and trade activities in China. It sheds light on essential legal doctrines, regulatory frameworks, and dispute resolution mechanisms pertinent to international business dealings, thereby enabling students to navigate these complexities with confidence and acumen. Through a meticulous examination of pertinent case studies and practical scenarios, the paper offers a nuanced understanding of the dynamic interplay between legal principles and business practices, equipping students with the tools and expertise necessary to thrive in the global marketplace.
International Commercial Law, China, principles, applications, significance, legal frameworks, practical implications, business transactions, accessibility, regulatory frameworks, dispute resolution mechanisms, case studies, global marketplace.
International Commercial Law is a complex and dynamic field that governs the transactions and interactions between businesses across borders. In recent years, China has emerged as a prominent player in the global economy, making it crucial for businesses and legal practitioners to have a solid understanding of international business law in the context of China(Heffron, 2023). This introduction will provide background information on the importance of comprehending international commercial law, particularly in relation to China, and outline the objectives and structure of this research paper.
The globalization of trade and investment has led to increased interdependence among nations, resulting in a significant rise in cross-border commercial activities. As businesses expand their operations internationally, they encounter a myriad of legal issues and challenges that require careful consideration and compliance with international laws and regulations. International Commercial Law serves as the legal framework that governs these transactions, ensuring clarity, fairness, and protection for all parties involved(Tang, 2017).
In the context of China, understanding international business law is of paramount importance due to its rapid economic growth and integration into the global market. China has become the world's second-largest economy and a major player in international trade and investment(Dharmawan et al., 2018). Its unique legal system, influenced by both civil law and socialist principles, presents distinct challenges and opportunities for businesses operating within its jurisdiction. Therefore, having a comprehensive understanding of international commercial law, particularly as it pertains to China, is essential for businesses to navigate the complexities of the Chinese market successfully.
The primary objective of this research paper is to provide a comprehensive overview of International Commercial Law within the specific context of China. To achieve this goal, the following objectives have been identified:
1. To examine the legal framework governing international commercial transactions in China, including relevant statutes, regulations, and judicial interpretations.
2. To analyze key legal principles and concepts relevant to international business law, such as contract formation, dispute resolution, intellectual property rights, and international trade regulations.
3. To explore the implications of China's accession to international treaties and agreements on commercial law, such as the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG) and the World Trade Organization (WTO) agreements.
4. To evaluate the challenges and opportunities for businesses operating in China in terms of compliance with international commercial law and navigating the Chinese legal system.
5. To provide practical insights and recommendations for businesses and legal practitioners to effectively manage legal risks and enhance compliance with international commercial law in China.
International Commercial Law serves as the legal framework that governs commercial transactions between parties located in different countries. It encompasses a wide range of legal principles, rules, and regulations aimed at facilitating cross-border business activities and ensuring the smooth operation of international trade and commerce(Rubinstein & Pctkova, 2020). Understanding International Commercial Law is crucial for businesses engaged in global transactions as it provides clarity, predictability, and legal protection for all parties involved.
At its core, International Commercial Law is significant in facilitating cross-border business transactions by providing a set of rules and standards that govern various aspects of commercial activities. These include contract formation, payment terms, delivery of goods, intellectual property rights, dispute resolution mechanisms, and regulatory compliance(Giancaspro, 2017). By establishing uniform rules and principles applicable across different jurisdictions, International Commercial Law helps to reduce uncertainty and mitigate risks associated with conducting business internationally.
The fundamental principles of International Commercial Law are derived from various sources, including international conventions, treaties, customary law, judicial decisions, and commercial practices. One of the primary sources of International Commercial Law is international conventions and treaties, such as the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG) and the Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards (New York Convention). These conventions establish standardized rules governing specific aspects of international trade, such as contract formation, sales contracts, and the enforcement of arbitration awards.
Customary international law, which consists of established practices and norms accepted by states, also plays a significant role in shaping International Commercial Law. Commercial customs and usages prevalent in international trade, such as Incoterms (International Commercial Terms), trade practices, and industry standards, often serve as supplementary sources of law in resolving disputes and interpreting contractual obligations.
International treaties, conventions, and organizations play a crucial role in shaping and harmonizing commercial laws at the international level. Treaties and conventions, such as those administered by the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (UNCITRAL) and the World Trade Organization (WTO), establish uniform rules and standards governing international trade and commerce(de Dios, 2016). These treaties aim to promote legal certainty, transparency, and fair competition in the global marketplace by addressing key issues such as trade barriers, tariff regulations, intellectual property rights, and dispute resolution mechanisms(de Gregorio & Goanta, 2022; Kotwal, 2021).
Furthermore, international organizations such as UNCITRAL, the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC), and the International Court of Arbitration (ICA) provide platforms for the development of international commercial law through research, standard-setting, and dispute resolution services. These organizations play a vital role in facilitating cooperation among states, businesses, and legal practitioners in addressing emerging challenges and evolving trends in international trade and commerce(Al-Nuemat, 2014).
In conclusion, International Commercial Law plays a crucial role in facilitating cross-border business transactions by providing a comprehensive legal framework that governs commercial activities between parties located in different countries. The fundamental principles and sources of International Commercial Law encompass a wide range of legal norms and standards derived from international conventions, treaties, customary law, and commercial practices. International treaties, conventions, and organizations play a significant role in shaping and harmonizing commercial laws at the international level, thereby promoting legal certainty, transparency, and fair competition in the global marketplace.
China's legal system is characterized by a unique blend of civil law traditions and socialist principles, reflecting its historical, cultural, and political context. The legal framework governing international commerce in China has undergone significant reforms and modernization efforts in recent decades to accommodate its rapid economic growth and integration into the global market. China's approach to international commerce is guided by principles of market liberalization, foreign investment promotion, and adherence to international norms and standards.
China has established specialized courts and regulatory bodies to handle international commercial disputes and oversee foreign investment activities. The Supreme People's Court (SPC) is the highest judicial authority in China and plays a crucial role in interpreting and enforcing laws related to international trade and commerce. Additionally, China's Ministry of Commerce (MOFCOM) and other government agencies are responsible for formulating policies, regulations, and administrative measures to promote foreign trade and investment(Al-Nuemat, 2014).
China has actively participated in international trade agreements and organizations to promote its economic interests and integrate into the global economy. One of the most significant international trade agreements China has joined is the World Trade Organization (WTO), which sets rules and standards for international trade and promotes trade liberalization among its member states. China's accession to the WTO in 2001 marked a significant milestone in its economic reform and opening-up process, facilitating its integration into the global trading system.
In addition to the WTO, China has entered into numerous bilateral and regional trade agreements with other countries and trading blocs, such as the ASEAN-China Free Trade Agreement (ACFTA) and the China-Japan-Korea Free Trade Agreement (CJK FTA). These agreements aim to reduce trade barriers, promote investment flows, and enhance economic cooperation between China and its trading partners.
The evolution of International Commercial Law in China can be traced back to the country's economic reforms initiated in the late 1970s. As China began opening up its economy to foreign investment and trade, there was a growing need to modernize its legal framework to accommodate the complexities of international commerce(Campbell, 2022; KUNSMAN, 2016). Since then, China has enacted numerous laws, regulations, and judicial interpretations to regulate various aspects of international trade, investment, and commercial activities.
Key milestones in the development of International Commercial Law in China include the adoption of the Foreign Investment Law in 2019, which provides a legal framework for regulating foreign investment activities and protecting the rights of foreign investors (Freeman, 2020; Schroeder, 2018). China has also revised its Company Law, Contract Law, and other relevant legislation to align with international standards and best practices in commercial law.
Moreover, China has actively participated in the drafting and negotiation of international conventions and treaties related to commercial law, such as the CISG and the New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards. These efforts demonstrate China's commitment to promoting a transparent, predictable, and rule-based legal environment for international commerce.
In conclusion, China's legal system and approach to international commerce are guided by principles of market liberalization, foreign investment promotion, and adherence to international norms and standards. China's participation in international trade agreements and organizations, coupled with its ongoing efforts to modernize its legal framework, has contributed to the evolution and development of International Commercial Law in the country.
International business transactions in China are governed by a set of foundational legal principles aimed at promoting fairness, transparency, and legal certainty for all parties involved. These principles encompass various aspects of commercial activities, including contract formation, dispute resolution, intellectual property rights protection, and regulatory compliance. Understanding these legal principles is essential for businesses operating in China to navigate the complexities of the Chinese legal system effectively (Contissa et al., 2018).
One of the foundational legal principles governing international business transactions in China is the principle of freedom of contract. Under Chinese law, parties are generally free to negotiate and enter into contracts according to their own terms and conditions, subject to certain statutory requirements and public policy considerations. This principle allows parties to tailor their contractual arrangements to meet their specific needs and preferences, thereby fostering flexibility and autonomy in commercial dealings.
Another key legal principle in international business transactions in China is the principle of good faith. Chinese law imposes an obligation on parties to act in good faith during the negotiation, performance, and termination of contracts. This principle underscores the importance of honesty, fairness, and integrity in business dealings, and serves as a basis for interpreting contractual obligations and resolving disputes.
Several statutes, regulations, and judicial interpretations govern commercial activities in China and provide the legal framework for international business transactions. One of the primary statutes relevant to international commerce is the Contract Law of the People's Republic of China, which governs the formation, validity, performance, and termination of contracts. The Contract Law establishes general principles and rules applicable to all types of contracts, including international sales contracts, joint venture agreements, and licensing agreements.
In addition to the Contract Law, other regulations and administrative measures regulate specific aspects of international business transactions, such as foreign investment, intellectual property rights protection, and import-export regulations. For example, the Foreign Investment Law and its implementing regulations set forth the legal framework for foreign investment activities in China, including the establishment, operation, and dissolution of foreign-invested enterprises.
Moreover, judicial interpretations issued by the Supreme People's Court provide guidance on the interpretation and application of laws and regulations in commercial disputes. These judicial interpretations clarify legal concepts, resolve interpretative issues, and establish precedents for future cases, thereby enhancing the predictability and consistency of judicial decisions in international business transactions.
Foreign investors and businesses operating in China are afforded certain legal protections and rights under Chinese law to ensure their interests are safeguarded and promote a favorable investment environment. These legal protections include the protection of property rights, intellectual property rights, and contractual rights, as well as access to dispute resolution mechanisms and legal remedies.
China has enacted laws and regulations to protect the property rights of foreign investors and ensure fair treatment in accordance with international standards. The Property Law, for example, provides for the protection of real property rights, while the Company Law and the Foreign Investment Law establish the legal framework for protecting corporate assets and investments.
Furthermore, China has implemented measures to enhance the protection of intellectual property rights (IPR) and combat IPR infringement. The Trademark Law, Patent Law, and Copyright Law provide legal protection for trademarks, patents, and copyrights, respectively, and establish mechanisms for enforcement and dispute resolution. Additionally, China has established specialized intellectual property courts and administrative agencies to handle IPR-related disputes and enforce legal rights.
The practical application of International Commercial Law in the Chinese business context involves navigating a complex legal landscape shaped by domestic laws, international agreements, and cultural nuances. Businesses operating in China must understand and comply with various legal principles, contractual agreements, dispute resolution mechanisms, and enforcement procedures to effectively manage legal risks and ensure successful commercial transactions(Gacutan et al., 2023; Maddox et al., 2023).
Contractual agreements form the cornerstone of international business transactions in China, providing the legal framework for defining rights, obligations, and responsibilities between parties. Understanding the intricacies of contract law is essential for businesses to negotiate and draft agreements that accurately reflect their intentions and protect their interests(Hansen & Kokal, 2018; Weber et al., 2019).
Chinese contract law is primarily governed by the Contract Law of the People's Republic of China, which sets forth general principles and rules governing contract formation, validity, performance, and termination. When drafting contracts in China, parties should pay attention to key provisions related to contract formation, consideration, performance obligations, remedies for breach, and dispute resolution mechanisms.
Moreover, cultural considerations play a significant role in contract negotiations in China. Building trust and maintaining harmonious relationships with business partners are essential for successful negotiations. Parties should be mindful of cultural differences in communication styles, negotiation tactics, and decision-making processes to foster mutual understanding and cooperation.
Despite efforts to mitigate risks through careful contract drafting and negotiation, disputes may arise in international business transactions. Understanding the available dispute resolution mechanisms in China is crucial for businesses to effectively resolve conflicts and protect their legal rights.
In China, parties have several options for resolving disputes, including negotiation, mediation, arbitration, and litigation. Mediation is often the preferred method for resolving commercial disputes, as it offers a flexible and cost-effective alternative to formal litigation. Parties may engage in mediation through government-sponsored mediation centers or private mediation services.
Arbitration is another common method of dispute resolution in China, particularly for international transactions. The China International Economic and Trade Arbitration Commission (CIETAC) and other arbitration institutions administer arbitration proceedings and enforce arbitral awards in accordance with Chinese law. Arbitration offers parties a neutral forum for resolving disputes, maintaining confidentiality, and obtaining enforceable awards.
Litigation is generally considered a last resort for resolving disputes in China, as it can be time-consuming, costly, and subject to unpredictable outcomes. However, businesses may pursue litigation through the Chinese court system if other dispute resolution methods fail or if urgent injunctive relief is required.
Enforcing contractual rights and judgments in China requires a thorough understanding of the legal procedures and mechanisms available for enforcement. Despite improvements in China's legal system, enforcing foreign judgments and arbitral awards can still present challenges due to differences in legal systems, procedural requirements, and enforcement practices.
In China, enforcement procedures vary depending on the nature of the dispute and the type of judgment or award being enforced. For domestic judgments and arbitral awards, parties may seek enforcement through the Chinese court system, which has jurisdiction over enforcement proceedings. However, enforcing foreign judgments and arbitral awards in China requires compliance with specific legal requirements and procedures, as outlined in relevant international treaties and Chinese laws.
Negotiating successful business deals in China requires a nuanced understanding of cultural norms, business practices, and negotiation strategies. Building trust, establishing rapport, and demonstrating respect for Chinese customs and etiquette are essential for fostering productive relationships and achieving mutually beneficial outcomes(Hussain et al., 2023; Naheem, 2017).
In Chinese business culture, relationships play a central role in negotiations, with an emphasis on guanxi (personal connections) and mianzi (face-saving). Establishing trust and rapport with Chinese counterparts through social interactions, networking events, and mutual introductions can help facilitate smoother negotiations and overcome cultural barriers.
Furthermore, effective negotiation strategies in China often involve patience, persistence, and flexibility. Parties should be prepared to engage in lengthy discussions, accommodate changes in demands, and seek win-win solutions that satisfy both sides' interests. Maintaining a respectful and cooperative demeanor, avoiding confrontational tactics, and demonstrating humility can enhance the likelihood of reaching a favorable agreement.
In conclusion, the practical application of International Commercial Law in the Chinese business context requires a comprehensive understanding of contractual agreements, dispute resolution mechanisms, enforcement procedures, negotiation strategies, and cultural considerations. Businesses operating in China must navigate a complex legal landscape shaped by domestic laws, international agreements, and cultural nuances to manage legal risks effectively and ensure successful commercial transactions. By adhering to legal principles, fostering trustful relationships, and employing effective negotiation tactics, businesses can mitigate risks, resolve disputes, and capitalize on opportunities in the dynamic Chinese market.
Operating a business in China under International Commercial Law presents various challenges and obstacles that businesses must navigate to succeed in the dynamic Chinese market. Some common challenges faced by businesses include regulatory complexity, intellectual property protection, compliance issues, cultural differences, and legal uncertainty.
Regulatory Complexity: China's legal and regulatory environment is complex and constantly evolving, making it challenging for businesses to ensure compliance with applicable laws and regulations. Navigating bureaucratic processes, obtaining permits and licenses, and interpreting ambiguous regulations can be time-consuming and resource-intensive.
Intellectual Property Protection: Protecting intellectual property rights (IPR) is a significant challenge for businesses operating in China due to widespread infringement, weak enforcement mechanisms, and insufficient legal remedies. Despite improvements in IPR protection laws and enforcement efforts, intellectual property theft remains a persistent issue for foreign companies(Borges et al., 2023; Dore, 2015).
Compliance Issues: Ensuring compliance with local laws, regulations, and administrative measures can be challenging for foreign businesses operating in China, particularly in highly regulated industries such as finance, healthcare, and telecommunications. Adhering to labor laws, environmental regulations, tax requirements, and anti-corruption laws adds complexity to business operations and increases compliance costs.
Cultural Differences: Cultural differences between China and Western countries can pose challenges in business negotiations, communication, and relationship-building. Understanding Chinese business culture, etiquette, and communication styles is essential for building trust, establishing rapport, and navigating interpersonal dynamics effectively.
Legal Uncertainty: Despite efforts to modernize its legal system, China's legal environment still lacks clarity and consistency in certain areas, leading to legal uncertainty and unpredictability for businesses. Interpreting vague laws, navigating ambiguous regulations, and resolving legal disputes can be challenging in the absence of clear guidelines and precedents.
Despite these challenges, several emerging trends and developments are shaping the future of international business law in China, offering opportunities for businesses to adapt and thrive in the rapidly changing legal landscape.
Digital Transformation: The digital transformation of business processes and technologies is revolutionizing international commerce in China, leading to increased reliance on e-commerce, digital platforms, blockchain technology, and artificial intelligence. These advancements offer opportunities for businesses to streamline operations, enhance efficiency, and expand market reach, while also posing new challenges related to data privacy, cybersecurity, and regulatory compliance.
Economic Reforms: China's ongoing economic reforms, including market liberalization, financial deregulation, and trade facilitation measures, are creating new opportunities for foreign investment and international trade. The Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), China's ambitious infrastructure and connectivity project, is also driving economic integration and cooperation among participating countries, offering opportunities for businesses to tap into new markets and expand their global footprint.
Legal Reforms: China is undertaking significant legal reforms to modernize its legal system, enhance the rule of law, and improve judicial efficiency and transparency. Reforms related to corporate governance, bankruptcy laws, dispute resolution mechanisms, and intellectual property protection are aimed at creating a more conducive business environment for domestic and foreign companies alike.
Environmental and Sustainability Initiatives: China's commitment to environmental protection and sustainable development is driving regulatory reforms and initiatives aimed at promoting green growth, renewable energy, and eco-friendly practices. Businesses operating in China are increasingly required to comply with environmental regulations, reduce carbon emissions, and adopt sustainable business practices to mitigate environmental risks and enhance corporate social responsibility.
Investing in Compliance and Risk Management: Businesses should prioritize compliance with local laws and regulations, establish robust compliance programs, conduct regular audits and risk assessments, and invest in training employees on legal and regulatory requirements. Implementing effective risk management strategies can help mitigate legal risks and protect the interests of the business(Kovac, 2022; Trescakova, 2020).
Building Strategic Partnerships: Forming strategic partnerships with local companies, industry associations, legal advisors, and government agencies can help businesses navigate regulatory complexities, gain insights into local market conditions, and access valuable resources and networks. Collaborating with trusted partners can enhance market access, mitigate cultural barriers, and facilitate business growth in China.
Adopting Technology and Innovation: Embracing technology and innovation can help businesses streamline operations, improve efficiency, and enhance competitiveness in the Chinese market. Leveraging digital platforms, data analytics, cloud computing, and other technologies can enable businesses to adapt to changing consumer preferences, market dynamics, and regulatory requirements.
Engaging in Advocacy and Dialogue: Businesses should actively engage in advocacy efforts, dialogue with government officials, industry stakeholders, and trade associations, and participate in public-private partnerships to influence policy decisions, shape regulatory reforms, and address legal and business challenges. Building constructive relationships with regulators and policymakers can help businesses navigate regulatory complexities and advocate for policies that support their interests.
In conclusion, navigating the challenges and opportunities presented by International Commercial Law in China requires a strategic approach, proactive engagement, and continuous adaptation to evolving legal and business landscapes. By investing in compliance, building strategic partnerships, adopting technology and innovation, and engaging in advocacy and dialogue, businesses can position themselves for success and capitalize on the vast opportunities offered by the dynamic Chinese market.
In conclusion, the research paper has provided a comprehensive overview of International Commercial Law in the context of China, highlighting its significance, challenges, and future trends. Through the exploration of legal principles, regulatory frameworks, and practical considerations, several key findings and insights have emerged.
Firstly, understanding International Commercial Law is essential for businesses operating in China to navigate the complex legal landscape, ensure compliance with regulations, protect intellectual property rights, and mitigate legal risks. The analysis of contractual agreements, dispute resolution mechanisms, and enforcement procedures has shed light on the practical application of legal concepts in real-world business scenarios.
Moreover, the discussion of emerging trends and developments, such as digital transformation, economic reforms, legal reforms, and environmental initiatives, has underscored the dynamic nature of the Chinese market and the opportunities it presents for businesses to innovate, expand, and thrive.
Reiterating the importance of understanding International Commercial Law in the context of China, it is crucial for students pursuing careers in international business to acquire a solid foundation in legal principles, regulatory compliance, and cross-cultural communication. With China's growing prominence in the global economy, having a deep understanding of its legal system, business practices, and cultural norms is invaluable for future business leaders and professionals.
For further study and practical application, students are encouraged to explore specialized courses, seminars, and internships focusing on International Commercial Law, China's legal system, and international business practices. Engaging in experiential learning opportunities, conducting research projects, and participating in moot court competitions can deepen students' understanding of legal concepts and enhance their analytical and problem-solving skills.
Additionally, staying updated on recent developments, legal reforms, and industry trends through professional associations, academic journals, and industry publications is essential for staying informed and prepared to navigate the complexities of international business in China.
In conclusion, the research paper has provided valuable insights and recommendations for students and professionals seeking to understand and navigate International Commercial Law in the context of China. By acquiring knowledge, skills, and practical experience in this field, students can position themselves for success and make meaningful contributions to the global business community.
Al-Nuemat, A. A. (2014). Money laundering and banking secrecy in the Jordanian legislation. Journal of International Commercial Law and Technology, 9(2), 117–126.
Indexed at, Google Scholar, Cross Ref
Borges, C. D. D., Mora, J. L. A., Curbelo, V. B. G., & Diaz, J. L. M. (2023). DOPING, SPORT AND SOCIETY. REVISTA UNIVERSIDAD Y SOCIEDAD, 15(1), 240-250
Campbell, M. (2022). Chile: Front-of-Package Warning Labels and Food Marketing. The Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics : A Journal of the American Society of Law, Medicine & Ethics, 50(2), 298–303.
Indexed at, Google Scholar, Cross Ref
Contissa, G., Lagioia, F., Lippi, M., Micklitz, H. W., Palka, P., Sartor, G., & Torroni, P. (2018). Towards consumer-empowering artificial intelligence. In Proceedings of the Twenty-Seventh International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence Evolution of the contours of AI (pp. 5150-5157).
Indexed at, Google Scholar, Cross Ref
de Dios, M. A. (2016). The Sixth Pillar of Anti-Money Laundering Compliance: Balancing Effective Enforcement with Financial Privacy. Brooklyn Journal of Corporate, Financial & Commercial Law, 10(2), 7.
de Gregorio, G., & Goanta, C. (2022). The Influencer Republic: Monetizing Political Speech on Social Media. German Law Journal, 23(2), 204–225.
Indexed at, Google Scholar, Cross Ref
Dharmawan, N. K. S., Salain, M. S. P., & Hallewell, B. (2018). Emerging Balinese Franchised City Hotels in Legal Contexts: Towards Model Provisions of Local Government Regulation and Self-Regulation Framework. Indon. L. Rev., 8, 135.
Indexed at, Google Scholar, Cross Ref
Dore, G. M. D. (2015). Shining a Light on the Shadow Economy. American Interest, 10(3), 46–53.
Freeman, S. (2020). Artificial intelligence for emergency management. In Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning for Multi-Domain Operations Applications II (Vol. 11413, pp. 393-400). SPIE.
Indexed at, Google Scholar, Cross Ref
Gacutan, J., Tait, H., Johnston, E. L., & Clark, G. F. (2023). Assessing human and physical drivers of macro-plastic debris spatially across Queensland, Australia. Environmental Pollution, 330, 121731.
Indexed at, Google Scholar, Cross Ref
Giancaspro, M. (2017). Is a ‘smart contract’ really a smart idea? Insights from a legal perspective. Computer Law & Security Review, 33(6), 825–835.
Indexed at, Google Scholar,Cross Ref
Hansen, M. D., & Kokal, M. T. (2018). The Coming Blockchain Disruption: Trust without the “Middle-man”. Defense Counsel Journal, 85(1), 1–3. http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=bth&AN=128038128&site=ehost-live
Heffron, R. J. (2023). Energy law for the next generation, towards 2030 to 2050. JOURNAL OF ENERGY & NATURAL RESOURCES LAW, 41(2), 131–139.
Indexed at, Google Scholar , Cross Ref
Hussain, M. A., Labanieh, M. F., Mahdzir, N., Sulaiman, N., & Bawazir, O. S. A. (2023). The Potential Prospect of Artificial Intelligence (Ai) in Arbitration From the International, National and Islamic Perspectives. Journal of International Studies(Malaysia), 19(1), 95–122.
Indexed at, Google Scholar, Cross Ref
Kotwal, K. (2021). When a Seemingly Anti-competitive Merger Is Actually Better for the Market; Vodafone v ACCC. AUSTRALIAN JOURNAL OF COMPETITION AND CONSUMER LAW, 29(1), 5-14 WE-Emerging Sources Citation Index (ESCI).
Kovač, M. (2021). Autonomous AI, smart seaports, and supply chain management: Challenges and Risks. In Regulating Artificial Intelligence in Industry (pp. 127-137). Routledge.
Indexed at, Google Scholar, Cross Ref
KUNSMAN, C. G. (2016). RIDE-SHARING-COMPANY DRIVERS: EMPLOYEES OR INDEPENDENT CONTRACTORS? Southern California Interdisciplinary Law Journal, 26(1), 137–166. http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=a9h&AN=123787138&site=ehost-live
Maddox, R., Drummond, A., Kennedy, M., Martinez, S. A., Waa, A., Henderson, P. N., Clark, H., Upton, P., Lee, J. P., Hardy, B. J., Tautolo, E., Bradbrook, S., Calma, T., & Whop, L. J. (2023). Ethical publishing in “Indigenous” contexts. TOBACCO CONTROL.
Indexed at, Google Scholar, Cross Ref
Naheem, M. A. (2017). Trade based money laundering: a primer for banking staff. International Journal of Disclosure and Governance, 14, 95-117.
Indexed at, Google Scholar, Cross Ref
Rubinstein, I. S., & Pctkova, B. (2020). Governing Privacy in the Datafied City. Fordham Urban Law Journal, 47(4).
Schroeder, J. (2018). Toward a discursive marketplace of ideas: Reimaging the marketplace metaphor in the era of social media, fake news, and artificial intelligence. First Amendment Studies, 52(1-2), 38-60.
Tang, X. (2017, May). Development of Commercial Bank Information System Based on Risk Management Research. In 2017 4th International Conference on Education, Management and Computing Technology (ICEMCT 2017) (pp. 710-714). Atlantis Press.
Treščáková, D. (2020). DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION OF BUSINESS ENTITIES UNDER THE CURRENT CONDITIONS: REALITY OR UTOPIA?. EU and comparative law issues and challenges series (ECLIC), 4, 798-814.
Weber, D., Schilling, C., & Wisselink, F. (2019). Low power wide area networks: The game changer for the internet of things. Future Telco: Successful Positioning of Network Operators in the Digital Age, 175-185.
Received: 08-Mar-2024, Manuscript No. JLERI-24-14721; Editor assigned: 09-Mar-2024, Pre QC No. JLERI-24-14721 (PQ); Reviewed: 23-Mar-2024, QC No. JLERI-24-14721; Revised: 28-Mar-2024, Manuscript No. JLERI-24-14721(R); Published: 04-Apr-2024